Edinburgh Research Archive logo

Edinburgh Research Archive

University of Edinburgh homecrest
View Item 
  •   ERA Home
  • Biological Sciences, School of
  • Biological Sciences thesis and dissertation collection
  • View Item
  •   ERA Home
  • Biological Sciences, School of
  • Biological Sciences thesis and dissertation collection
  • View Item
  • Login
JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

Understanding the phenotype of aggressiveness

View/Open
ClarkCC_2007redux.pdf (25.71Mb)
Date
2007
Author
Clark, Corinna Catherine Alicia
Metadata
Show full item record
Abstract
 
 
Mixing together unfamiliar pigs is a common husbandry practice in commercial indoor piggeries that causes a period of intense fighting and aggression between pigs, resulting in elevated stress responses and injuries to those involved. Frequency, duration and intensity of aggressive behaviour have been found to differ between individuals. There is some evidence that these differences are due to trait-aggressiveness, as consistency of responses to similar challenges has been demonstrated. This trait-aggressiveness may be linked to other behavioural (social and non-social) and physiological traits to fonn part of personality. To understand aggression in the context of behavioural trait the prevalence o f aggression was studied throughout the lifetime o f a cohort of pigs, examining consistency within and between situations at numerous points. M ore specifically, the aims o f this thesis were to investigate: whether the relative magnitude of aggression displayed in response to a repeated social challenge test (Resident Intruder Test) was consistent over time; if this aggressiveness changed with age and experience; whether RIT aggressiveness was comparable to, or predictive o f aggressiveness during social mixing; what strategies were employed by pigs of differing aggressiveness during mixing; and finally, if aggressiveness was linked to the response of individual pigs to a challenging environment, unconnected to social confrontation (maternal behaviour).
 
Detailed behavioural analysis was performed on the progeny o f 19 gilts. Consistency of aggressiveness was examined using repeated Resident Intruder Tests at various key stages during the lifetime o f male and female growing pigs, and a subset of female breeding pigs. Behaviour during mixing at weaning and as gilts was examined in detail; information was collected about the way in which these animals behaved in a social context, including nonaggressive social behaviour, and how this related to injuries received (lesions). As social dominance status is often cited as a parameter related to aggressiveness, this was recorded at various stages using a group feeding competition test and compared to behavioural measures from mixing and the RIT. To gain a better understanding of the interaction between aggressiveness and other traits, the various measures of aggressiveness were compared with cortisol (as a physiological indicator of the relative stress responses of individuals) and the behaviour of a subset of female pigs in the period immediately preceding and following farrowing. Maternal behaviour was chosen for comparison to aggressiveness as it is also potentially a trait-behaviour, specific to individuals, that is not obviously linked to social aggressiveness; but also because it is both important commercially and for the welfare of the gilts and piglets.
 
Detailed behavioural analysis was performed on the progeny o f 19 gilts. Consistency of aggressiveness was examined using repeated Resident Intruder Tests at various key stages during the lifetime o f male and female growing pigs, and a subset of female breeding pigs. Behaviour during mixing at weaning and as gilts was examined in detail; information was collected about the way in which these animals behaved in a social context, including nonaggressive social behaviour, and how this related to injuries received (lesions). As social dominance status is often cited as a parameter related to aggressiveness, this was recorded at various stages using a group feeding competition test and compared to behavioural measures from mixing and the RIT. To gain a better understanding of the interaction between aggressiveness and other traits, the various measures of aggressiveness were compared with cortisol (as a physiological indicator of the relative stress responses of individuals) and the behaviour of a subset of female pigs in the period immediately preceding and following farrowing. Maternal behaviour was chosen for comparison to aggressiveness as it is also potentially a trait-behaviour, specific to individuals, that is not obviously linked to social aggressiveness; but also because it is both important commercially and for the welfare of the gilts and piglets.
 
Pigs were consistent in their responses to the RIT, but there were differences between sexes. RIT aggressiveness was consistent over a long period of time in female pigs, even with a gap of 90 days between tests and the onset o f puberty. M ale pigs showed an unexpectedly high level of mounting behaviour from a young age, which increased with maturity. Experience of the RIT improved consistency o f responses, and age at first testing affected both the speed of attacking and occurrence of attacks: those pigs experiencing the test when younger were more likely to and quicker to attack. Although aggression in the RIT was consistent, it was not predictive o f subsequent aggressiveness at mixing.
 
As with the RIT, there were clear sex-differences observed during mixing at weaning, with males being more aggressive, more successful in fights, more likely to mount and less likely to play than females. Pigs employed different strategies during mixing, the extremes of which were categorised by high-play-low-aggressiveness and vice versa. As expected, aggressive individuals were involved in more fights and won more fights, but suffered more skin lesions than non-aggressive individuals. Pigs that engaged in high-playing were generally the least successful in fights, but suffered fewer lesions and had equal ultimate dominance rank to aggressive pigs. The behavioural structure of mixing changed between weaning and puberty, with differences in the occurrence and duration of aggressive and nonaggressive behaviours. Fighting ceased sooner during the gilt mix, but aggression was more frequent and more severe. Comparisons with maternal behaviour found gilts that reacted aggressively to their piglets were more aggressive and successful in the mix and more ‘reactive’ during farrowing. There were other links between farrowing and mixing behaviour, such as more frequent posture changes but less frequent nesting with greater mixaggressiveness; indicating that aggressiveness and maternal behaviour traits are linked through personality.
 
The RIT was not a reliable predictor o f aggressiveness, particularly in male pigs. Aggressiveness did not always equate to status as some individuals managed to attain rank without severe fighting or receiving excessive numbers of lesions. It may be that aggressive pigs are more reactive in a number o f situations, reactivity to piglets during farrowing being one of these situations. The results indicate that aggression should not be viewed in isolation, but with other traits that make up personality. Rather than being a fixed entity, aggressiveness develops with age, sex, experience and enviromnental influences.
 
URI
http://hdl.handle.net/1842/27801
Collections
  • Biological Sciences thesis and dissertation collection

Library & University Collections HomeUniversity of Edinburgh Information Services Home
Privacy & Cookies | Takedown Policy | Accessibility | Contact
Privacy & Cookies
Takedown Policy
Accessibility
Contact
feed RSS Feeds

RSS Feed not available for this page

 

 

All of ERACommunities & CollectionsBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsPublication TypeSponsorSupervisorsThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsPublication TypeSponsorSupervisors
LoginRegister

Library & University Collections HomeUniversity of Edinburgh Information Services Home
Privacy & Cookies | Takedown Policy | Accessibility | Contact
Privacy & Cookies
Takedown Policy
Accessibility
Contact
feed RSS Feeds

RSS Feed not available for this page