Edinburgh Research Archive logo

Edinburgh Research Archive

University of Edinburgh homecrest
View Item 
  •   ERA Home
  • Edinburgh Medical School
  • Edinburgh Medical School thesis and dissertation collection
  • View Item
  •   ERA Home
  • Edinburgh Medical School
  • Edinburgh Medical School thesis and dissertation collection
  • View Item
  • Login
JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

Congenital hypertrophic pyloric stenosis: a study of the pathology, diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis with reference to seventeen personal cases

View/Open
CowanAF_1937redux.pdf (15.64Mb)
Date
1937
Author
Cowan, A. F.
Metadata
Show full item record
Abstract
 
 
The condition of Congenital Hypertrophic Pyloric Stenosis, also commonly called Congenital Pyloric Stenosis, or Pyloric Stenosis in Infants, may be shortly defined as "A disease in which symptoms of increasing pyloric obstruction arise in children under three months of age" (Parsons and Barling).
 
In our opinion the full title Congenital Hyper - trophic Pyloric Stenosis is the most desirable in that it implies the congenital nature of the malady, and emphasises the muscular hypertrophy of the pyloric canal so constantly found post mortem and at operation in these cases.
 
Our study of Congenital Hypertrophic Pyloris Stenosis has shown it to be a condition associated with pathological changes of a constant and well defined nature. A marked hypertrophy of the pylorus, caused by local gigantism of the circular muscle fibres constituting the wall of the pyloric canal, is the most striking feature of the pathology. We believe that this circular muscle hypertrophy affects only the pyloric antrum and canal, and does not occur in the pyloric ring sphincter. Such hypertrophy of the circular muscle layer, combined with the protrusion of the mucosa into the lumen of the pyloric canal, constitutes a relative obstruction. Our observations have, however, convinced us that an element of spasm is essential, if complete obstruction of the pyloric canal is to occur. The pathological appearances and clinical features of this condition have led us to support the view held by John Thomson in regard to the pathogenesis of Congenital Hyperthrophic Pyloric Stenosis; no one has yet been able to explain why there is a want of co- ordination between the sympathetic and parasympathetic fibres supplying this area, but no doubt the explanation will emerge as our knowledge of the function and control of the sympathetic ganglia increases. There is an impression amongst doctors that Congenital Hypertrophic Pyloric Stenosis is a rare condition, and that the clinical diagnosis requires the skill, perception, and acumen of a paediatric specialist. It is true that careful observation and repeated examination may be necessary before the four cardinal signs and symptoms are ascertained, but when present their observation and significance should at once suggest the diagnosis to the family doctor. Elaborate clinical methods of investigation are neither necessary nor desirable in order to make an accurate diagnosis; the occurrence of forceful vomiting in a first born, male infant, under three months of age, is highly suggestive of the condition and if, in addition, visible gastric peristalsis can be seen and constipation exists the diagnosis is almost certain, The palpation of a pyloric tumour is, in our experience, the least commonly demonstrable sign; we believe that failure to elicit this sign is seldom due to lack of perception on the part of the examiner, but rather to the anatomical position of the tumour beneath the lower border of the liver. Consideration of the subsidiary symptoms and signs, while not essential for clinical diagnosis, will undoubtedly help to make the diagnosis more certain in the difficult case. Recent observations on the existence and. manifestations of alkalosis in this condition constitute an important advance in our knowledge, by facilitating diagnosis, and awakening a new consciousness of the risk of surgery without adequate preoperative preparation.
 
The differential diagnosis of IIypertrophic Steno-: sis from Pyloric Spasm and Duodenal Obstruction should not present any great difficulty if the different sex incidence, earlier onset, and tendency to hypertonicity in the former, and the presence of bile in the vomitus in the latter are borne in mind by the physician. Turning now to the question of treatment in Congenital Hypertrophia pyloric Stenosis, we are of the opinion that the results achieved do not justify the adoption of medical measures alone in the treatment of this condition. The optimam chance of recovery for the infant lies in the closest co- operation between the physician and the surgeon; the initial stages of treatment should be medical, so that while the general condition of the patient is being improved coincident observations can be made which will ensure the speedy formation of a definite diagnosis in the physician's mind. The determination of the psychological moment at which to operate is a matter which the physician must decide for himself, aided by his past experience of these cases; early operation, as soon as a definite diagnosis has been made and the infant's condition improved, undoubtedly holds the best promise of a successful cure . We would strongly urge the desirability of with continuation. breast feeding in these cases if at all possible; early operation to ensure the continuance of breast feeding during convalescence is a procedure always attended with the best results. From our limited experience we have formed the opinion that : umydri.n is an antispasmodic drug well worthy of a trial, in the event of careful feeding combined with gastric lavage proving unsuccessful in diminishing the frequency of projectile vomiting.
 
The classical Fredet- Pammstedt operation has now become the standard method of surgical treatment in this condition, and has proved to be the simplest and most efficacious procedure yet devised. The ultimate success of this operation depends in large measure upon careful pre -operative preparation, which aims at improving the :general condition and resistance of the patient, while also rendering the operation simple in execution and minimising the serious risk of post -óperative complications. The adequate administration of fluid before operation is of considerable importance, not only does this procedure tend to improve the general condition of the infant and counteract operative shock, but it also allays the very real danger of alkalosis before operation which has recently been stressed by Maize is and Morris. We believe that blood transfusion holds pride of place in the pre -operative measures adopted to compensate for the anaemic, emaciated, dehydrated state of many of these infants before operation; the routine adoption of such treatment would, we believe, very substantially reduce the operative mortality by putting the infant in the best position to withstand the shock of operation. Preliminary gastric lavage and the administration of a mild hypnotic greatly facilitate the safe and speedy execution of the operation, by rendering the stomach easy to handle, and reducing movement to the minimum. In the presence of these favourable conditions the operative technique is simple in execution and the hazards few, if the operator. is full;; alive to the danger of perforating the duodenum or closing the abdomen before satisfactory haeuostasis has been secured in the operative field. Once completed the success or failure of the operation depends in large measure upon the subsequent nursing of the infant. Small frequent feeds preferably of breast milk, the supplementary administration of fluid, and the maximum of sleep in warm surroundings will go far to ensure a speedy and successful recovery.
 
Post -operative complications should be of infrequent occurrence in the rands of an experienced surgeon, who has made a careful inspection of the pylorus before returning it to the abdomen, and has repaired the abdominal wall to the best of his ability when closing the wound. A high standard of nursing and the short time spent in hospital probably explain the fact that we have not experienced the dread results of enteritis after operation; this risk can, we believe, be still further reduced by nursing these cases in an isolation ward.
 
Despite the very satisfactory results of surgical treatment in Congenital Hypertrophie Pyloric Stenosis the prognosis should always be guarded. At the present time the lives of many infants suffering from this condition. are needless lost owing to long delay in diagnosis, foolhardy experiments with medical treatment, and a lack of appreciation of the correct time at which to operate. The very low mortality amongst private cases emphasises the fact that early diagnosis and prompt treatment affects the mortality very favourably, and for this reason we hope that in the future every family doctor will be alive to the possibility of Congenital Hypertrophic Pyloric Stenosis, whenever he is called to see an infant with persistent vomiting, visible gastric peristalsis, and progressive constipation, and that he will act imrnediately to safeguard the best interests of his patient.
 
URI
http://hdl.handle.net/1842/30975
Collections
  • Edinburgh Medical School thesis and dissertation collection

Library & University Collections HomeUniversity of Edinburgh Information Services Home
Privacy & Cookies | Takedown Policy | Accessibility | Contact
Privacy & Cookies
Takedown Policy
Accessibility
Contact
feed RSS Feeds

RSS Feed not available for this page

 

 

All of ERACommunities & CollectionsBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsPublication TypeSponsorSupervisorsThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsPublication TypeSponsorSupervisors
LoginRegister

Library & University Collections HomeUniversity of Edinburgh Information Services Home
Privacy & Cookies | Takedown Policy | Accessibility | Contact
Privacy & Cookies
Takedown Policy
Accessibility
Contact
feed RSS Feeds

RSS Feed not available for this page