A Comparison of the Higher-order and Hierarchical Model of Human Cognitive Ability Structure Using Nested Models Confirmatory Factor Analysis
Item statusRestricted Access
Murray, Aja Louise
Nested models confirmatory factor analysis was used to compare a higher-order and hierarchical model of human cognitive ability structure. In a higher-model the effects of g on observed subtest scores are completely mediated by lower-order, more specific ability factors. In a hierarchical model, the effects of both g and specific abilities on observed subtest scores are direct and independent. In two batteries of 20 and 21 cognitive tests taken from the Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart, the hierarchical model was better fitting than the higher-order model. Although g was by far the stronger influence on cognitive performance, there were important specific ability influences on cognitive performance independent of this. To avoid conflating these independent influences, the adoption of a hierarchical measurement model for empirical investigations in human cognitive abilities is recommended. Analyses also suggested that comparisons of higher-order and hierarchical analyses should involve comparisons of local fit criteria and not just rely on global fit statistics. This is because unmodelled complexity can potentially introduce biases into comparisons of the higher-order and hierarchical modal that are not discernable using only global fit statistics.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Modelling geographic phenomena at multiple levels of detail: A model generalisation approach based on aggregation Chaudhry, Omair (2008)Considerable interest remains in capturing once geographical information at the fine scale, and from this, automatically deriving information at various levels of detail and scale via the process of map generalisation. ...
Lavidas, George (The University of Edinburgh, 2016-11-29)The benefits of the Oceans and Seas have been exploited by societies for many centuries; the marine offshore and naval sectors have been the predominant users of the waters. It has been overlooked until recently, that ...
Verification and validation of a DEM-CFD model and multiscale modelling of cohesive fluidization regimes Gupta, Prashant (The University of Edinburgh, 2015-06-29)Fluidization of solid particles using gas flow is an important process in chemical and pharmaceutical industries. The dynamics of fluidisation are intricately related to particle scale physics. Fluid-particle interactions ...