Pain, Helen

Robertson, David

Conlon, Thomas Hugh

2013-07-02T10:55:20Z

2013-07-02T10:55:20Z

1997

The technology of knowledge-based systems undoubtedly offers potential for educational modelling, yet its practical impact on today's school classrooms is very limited. To an extent this is because the tools presently used in schools are EMYCIN -type expert system shells. The main argument of this thesis is that these shells make knowledge-based modelling unnecessarily difficult and that tools which exploit knowledge acquisition technologies empower learners to build better models. We describe how such tools can be designed. To evaluate their usability a model-building course was conducted in five secondary schools. During the course pupils built hundreds of models in a common range of domains. Some of the models were built with an EMYCIN -type shell whilst others were built with a variety of knowledge acquisition systems. The knowledge acquisition systems emerged as superior in important respects. We offer some explanations for these results and argue that although problems remain, such as in teacher education, design of classroom practice, and assessment of learning outcomes, it is clear that knowledge acquisition systems offer considerable potential to develop improved forms of educational knowledge-based modelling.

http://hdl.handle.net/1842/7514

en

The University of Edinburgh

Bird, D., Conlon, T. & Swanson. J. (1996). Computing and Information Technology in Higher Still: Let's get IT right. Scottish Educational Review Vol. 28 No. 1 pp3-15.

Conlon, T. (1985). Start Problem-solving with Prolog. Wokingham: Addis on-Wesley.

Conlon, T. (1991). Prolog and Educational Software. In: Prolog and Knowledge Bases in Schools. Commission of the European Communities, ECSC-EEC-EAEC, Brussels.

Conlon, T. (1993). PathFinder: a programming tool for searchbased problem solving. In: Brna, P., Ohlsson, S., & Pain, A. (Eds). Proceedings of AIED 93: World Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Education, Edinburgh.

Conlon, T. (1995). Automated Analysis for Knowledge-based Modelling. In: Vanneste, P., Bertels, K., & De Decker, B. (Eds) Proceedings of the Workshop on Automated (Novice) Program Analysis. AIED 95: World Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Education, Washington DC. pp31-37. Also available as DAI Research Paper No. 757, Department of Artificial Intelligence, University of Edinburgh.

Conlon, T. & Bowman, N. (1995). Expert Systems, Shells, and Schools: Present Practice, Future Prospects. Instructional Science Vol. 23 Nos 1-3 pp111-131.

Conlon, T. & Cope, P. (1989). Computing in Scottish Education: the First Decade and Beyond. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

Conlon, T. & Pain, H. (1995). Persistent Collaboration: marrying the technology push with the learning pull. In: Greer, J. (Ed). Proceedings of AI-ED 95: World Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Education, Washington DC. pp437-444.

Conlon, T. & Pain, H. (1996). Persistent Collaboration: A Methodology for Applied AI ED. Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education, Vol 7 No. 3/4 219-252. Also available as DAI Research Paper No. 790, Department of Artificial Intelligence, University of Edinburgh.

knowledge-based systems

EMYCIN

knowledge-based modelling

knowledge acquisition

Beyond rules: development and evaluation of knowledge acquisition systems for educational knowledge-based modelling

Thesis or Dissertation

Doctoral

PhD Doctor of Philosophy